Friday, March 2, 2012

The Tropic of Chaos

Overall, this book was great. I loved how Parenti brought the events in his book to life. The best way to really understand other cultures is to look at 'case studies' of individuals and how they view what goes on. I did catch some inconsistencies in the book, but because of the spirit of the book and the fact that it was obviously written to bring attention to an area of research that has not been paid much attention previously, I could still read the book and not be bothered too much. What I took from the book was Parenti's main idea of 'catastrophic convergence', that climate change is interacting with and accelerating cultural and historical factors that already existed.

What I found interesting about the book was that the 'Tropic of Chaos' located in the Inter-tropical Convergence Zone did not include some of the areas he talked about, and some of the areas he should have included in the book were nowhere to be found. I would have liked to learn even more about places not often on the news such as Vietnam, Cambodia, and Papua New Guinea. However, there is only so much information that can be included in a book while still remaining connected to the main idea and not seem like the author is rambling. Another aspect of climate change I would have liked to hear more about is how the warmer temperatures worldwide are affecting plant and animal populations. Parenti goes over the melting glaciers and the effect global warming is having on agriculture, but not much about how it is affecting natural vegetation and wild animal species. I would also be interested to hear about how global warming is affecting populations that live solely of the land (hunter-gatherers). An important connection I think the author made was between the climate change being experienced in Afghanistan and their subsequent switch to growing poppy instead of other crops. It added another facet to the culture of the Taliban, and made me understand more why they have support from the local populations (the Taliban protects poppy farmers from NATO forces fighting against the drug trade).

After finishing the last chapter of the book, I was sitting thinking about the main idea; how climate change was accelerating violence in certain parts of the world. For a long time, assumingly because of the news I’ve been exposed to about Afghanistan/Iraq/Pakistan, I have thought that the violence there is caused by ‘bad people’, like the people who are born and raised in these countries are just bad because of their culture or their religion. However, after thinking more about it and putting some of my psychology knowledge to work, I came up with a different conclusion. I’m not sure if anyone reading this has heard of the Stanford Prison Experiment, but it was an experiment done at Stanford University in 1971 that took students and put them in either guard or prisoner positions. What happened was amazing. The participants took it very seriously; the guards were brutal and the prisoners all had a horrible time – some needed years of therapy afterwards. But the main idea of the study was to see what would happen when good people were put in an evil place. Their question was essentially: Does good nature trump institution? The answer to this question was no. All participants in the study were ‘good’ people, but became violent under these circumstances. Mind you, all participants were men, but it still can apply because most of the ‘bad people’ we think of in Middle Eastern countries are men. They may not all be inherently bad because of their culture or religion. It may be that they are good people, but growing up in such a bad place has hardened them. It may not be entirely appropriate to place all blame on their religion, though following a fundamentalist religion has been proven to  have the side effect of a decrease in overall happiness.

Overall, I am very glad I read this book. I learned a lot about the history of continents I don’t hear about very often, and I also learned about the struggles of the populations in the Tropic of Chaos. My thoughts after reading the book are that climate change is certainly having a negative impact on many countries, making it difficult for them to continue positive development. Help is needed, but because the historical and cultural aspects of these countries are rooted in oppression by countries like the United States and sometimes even the United States itself, it may be hard for them to accept the help. NGO’s and humanitarian groups are doing a great job, but more obviously needs to be done, with a certain respect for culture (like not putting a well smack in the middle of a dividing line between two warring populations).

2 comments:

  1. Great post..I also agree that when I read this book, it is honestly one of the best books i've read in college.It felt like I wasn't reading as if it were an assignment but just for fun. I also liked how Parenti was specific when it came to talking about individuals than leading up to the countries overall issues. This book also changed my outlook on how countries adapt when everything around them is not going great. I enjoyed the stories of the guerilla wars in the majority of the countries overall it is a great book and I agree with Parenti in his beliefs.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very solid post. I agree with your sentiments about the topic of this book. I too found it interesting and appealing, even if Parenti contradicted himself occasionally. The information provided was certainly enlightening, and it opened my eyes to several obscure global economic and political issues.

    ReplyDelete