Sunday, February 26, 2012

Water Flows or Blood

It is almost impossible to imagine a natural disaster that killed two thousand people and left fourteen million in need of humanitarian aid. 2.4 million hectares of farmland was swept away and 1.9 million homes were destroyed, leaving 7 million people without a home after the 2010 Arabian Ocean Monsoon that flooded 20% of Afghanistan. In the United States, our biggest recent natural disaster was Hurricane Katrina, and while I will always remember the video of those displaced after all the flooding and destruction, I still can’t picture the scale of what must have been lost after the monsoon in Afghanistan. To fully understand the extent of the effect of climate change on places like Afghanistan, Pakistan, India, etc., it is important to have knowledge of the political, cultural, and historical context of the destruction. In places lacking in infrastructure, bouncing back from a large-scale natural disaster is a monumental undertaking and in most circumstances never fully happens.
In chapter 9, I was very interested in how opium, because of its minimal water needs, has taken hold in Afghanistan as one of its chief exports. It is another part of ‘law enforcement’ in Afghanistan that I never think about. NATO forces try to shut down poppy farmers, but because the crop is so profitable, the Taliban defends it and therefore gets the loyalty of the farmers who enjoy the Taliban’s protection. In chapter 11, I was interested to read about the disputes over the Kashmir region and how even this is related to Pakistan’s support of the Taliban (because India and Pakistan are fighting over control of the rivers that flow in this region, Pakistan supports the Taliban presence in Afghanistan because it makes the country a weaker ally for India). Finally, in chapter 12, I was saddened to hear about how many farmers, because of drought and subsequent lack of resources to grow crops, have resorted to suicide out of desperation. 150,000 farmers committed suicide between 1997 and 2005. That’s a substantial number...  It amazes me that banks in this region, instead of supporting the local economy by encouraging cultivation of a diverse number of crops, only support the growth of cotton because it ensures that the farmers and their starving families will not skim a little bit of their product off the top so they can have something to eat. Added to this, the cotton grown is killing the land because it is genetically engineered and does not allow for biodiversity, and therefore the development of a healthy ecosystem.
It seems to me that most of the things going on in the regions we have been reading about in this book are the result of greed and lack of respect for others. I do not think that it is right of me to judge the people in these countries for taking advantage of each other, because I cannot even come close to understanding what they are going through, but it seems like throughout history, more good has come out of working together than from one group milking the weaker parts of the population for all they have and then controlling them. People may just be trying to get by the only way they know how. This is a reason why first-world countries like the United States should be sending aid to help with irrigation projects and well-drilling. But even the best intentions can become skewed when there is little oversight and greed comes into play. In the book, Parenti mentions that there are NGO’s operating in places like Afghanistan that are charging money to drill wells, a service that should be free. 

Quiz Question: What fraction of India’s population consists of farmers?
Research Question: How can some of the agricultural irrigation techniques used in the United States be applied to the hardships currently being experienced in the Middle East?

3 comments:

  1. It is depressing to read that farmers committed suicide due to the conditions they are in as well as their land is in. It is also depressing to read that one farmer committed suicide by drinking pesticide, I believe. I agree that the best intentions can become skewed, especially when the United States gets involved. I think that majority of the time when the United States steps into a country to help, the country does not approve. This disapproval then leads to violence. However, if the United States did not get involved, there would still be violence. It's a risky situation and can result to a lose-lose situation.

    ReplyDelete
  2. To continue with what Erika was talking about, it's a very difficult decision whether America should go into a country and try to "fix" it. This is a very touchy subject right now because of the recent activity in Afghanistan. I too was saddened by the number of farmers that have committed suicide between 1997 and 2005. 150,000 farmers is a tremendous number. I also found it sad that banks in that region won't support their local economies. Something sounds corrupt about that idea

    ReplyDelete
  3. Kristin, Thank you for the very insightful posting. I agree that what starts as an attempt to help often morphs into something else -- often because of the attraction of power and control over other states. But who is to provide oversight when wealthy countries, people, organizations are involved? It isn't always a negative thing to charge people, but it depends on where the money goes I think. Habitat for Humanity does not give houses away free - people have to buy them. But, the money goes back into the account for advancing the funds to build a home for someone else. This organization has it down and does it right in my opinion.

    ReplyDelete