Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Winning the War on War


The last four chapters of Winning the War on War were pretty predictable, and the ending/conclusion was overly positive/optimistic. The author devotes a whole chapter to overviewing how progress in minimizing wars can be measured and the issues with each method. He then goes over three myths about present wars, namely the war in the congo. Third, he reviews the current wars in the world, none of which he is proud to admit, are ‘big wars’. The last chapter is essentially a call for support both monetarily and culturally for the UN and its missions.
Overall, the book taught me a lot about the UN’s history, how wars have waxed and waned over the years, and the current state of wars worldwide. I don’t know if I would recommend it to anyone else to read; it is one of those books that is pretty easy to summarize. The author obviously wrote it to fulfill one of his main goals outlined at the end of the book about creating more positive support for the UN and its missions worldwide.
Quiz Question: What are some of the issues with measuring the assessment of wars by counting the number of wars in a certain period of time?
Research Question: What is the best way to assess the ebb and flow of wars over time so that they can be compared (e.g. the social change they inspire, body count, economic effect, cost, international awareness of the war, or bloodiness/intensity /brutal nature of the killings during the war)?

Saturday, March 17, 2012

Kony 2012

            I thought the video was really inspiring. It is great that people are using social networking in this way; to spread knowledge about parts of the world that are, for all intents and purposes, ignored. I think that people, when they hear about men like Kony, feel like they want to do something, but don’t know where to start. If people are not in a group, they don’t feel as though they belong and usually conform to what everyone else is doing, which in this case is ignoring war crimes. What this video accomplishes is awesome, and without the internet and more importantly the help of social networking sites it would have never caught on.
The way they presented the problem and proposed solution to capturing Kony makes it seem simple. But capturing one man out of all of the people in that area of Africa (especially because he is now spreading out of Uganda) may not be doable even with the help and guidance of U.S. forces. If he is not caught, this campaign may be written off as too naïve/optimistic, and campaigns like it in the future may not catch on. People don’t like to fail, especially if they personally have campaigned for a cause and spread knowledge about it to friends/family members. Although the campaign may not be successful, it has still succeeded in one of its goals: make Kony famous. It has also worked to get some of the bigger names in Hollywood to speak out about the cause.
I have thought for a long time that social networking can work to spread knowledge about the world. If there was some way for people to get in contact with their representatives through something like a social networking site and let them know what they most care about, I think this would be a great thing. I have talked to a lot of people who don’t bother voting or talking to their representatives because they don’t think they will be listened to. Having a site that puts trends and issues voters care about in one place that the representatives can have access to would give them a better idea of what their constituents care about and allow them to better serve the people.

Thursday, March 15, 2012

Peace and Justice


Chapters 5-8 in Winning the War on War overview the many ways the UN and other international agencies define and secure peace worldwide. The author touches on subjects such as the peacekeeping toolbox, the big five African missions currently being undertaken by the UN, The Unarmy, and  peace movements. The first subject that caught my attention was how countries are dealt with after the active violence/war has subsided. There are many things the UN does after this time to ensure that the level of violence experienced never occurs again. The main tactic that I thought was interesting were the truth commissions. Last semester, I took an anthropology course called ‘culture in mind’, in which we talked about the ‘globalization of the American psyche’. One of the subjects we talked about in class was how psychologists that go to work in other countries are faced with the sometimes daunting task of finding out how local populations respond to certain situations such as wars or natural disasters. PTSD does not show up in all cultures in the same way, and therefore cannot be treated in the same way. The idea of the truth commissions, as outlined by the author of Winning the War on War, is that a successful truth commission can help overcome postwar denial and help a society deal with psychological trauma. However, having truth commissions may not always be the best way to deal with psychological trauma. Certain cultures may have their own way of dealing with those who commit crimes, lie, murder, and engage in war activities. In this way, truth commissions may just be another way that the US/other more powerful nations involved in the running of the UN think that their way is ‘best’, without stopping to study the cultures they are dealing with and finding solutions that fit their unique ways of life.
Quiz Question: What are the ‘Big Five’ African missions?
Research Question: In what kinds of cultures would truth commissions be detrimental to the psychological recovery of the population after a war?

Tuesday, March 13, 2012

A Revolution in Four Part Harmony

       Amandla! looked at the history of South Africa during apartheid in a very interesting way. The songs sung throughout apartheid connected the people, it was a way for them to express their anger and sadness about what was going on around them without blindly acting out in vengeful ways, which would definitely not have been as effective. It gave the oppressed a way to connect to their roots and band together during hard times. Struggle during apartheid gave rise to the songs that shaped its eventual outcome. The songs changed over the years as the struggle became more militarized, and continue to be sung today to commemorate the struggle and those lost.
       What was most interesting to me was the way in which South Africans sang their songs. The songs could be about killing white people or about certain heroes of theirs, but all were sung with the same facial expressions and essentially the same feeling to the melody. It is almost as though all feeling can be expressed through song without the need to cry while singing or laugh while singing. I was especially amazed when one woman was singing a happy-sounding song about struggle and those that were lost after talking about friends who had died during apartheid, and that she was smiling and looked glad which she was singing it but then all of a sudden she completely changed facial expressions and started to cry.
       On a more modern note, I think that songs have lost a lot of their meaning. There are still bands who write songs about climate change, war, social struggle, and love, but a lot of the songs out there today are about consumerism and having sex and committing violence. I think that maybe if songs today had more deep meaning, it could change the way young people look at the world, since they are the largest consumers of mainstream music.

Saturday, March 10, 2012

Establishing Sovereignty and Democracy


Chapters 1-4 of Winning the War on War were about the introduction of the book, the decline in wars worldwide, the history of world violence through wars and the role the UN has played in previous conflicts. While I do believe the world is becoming less violent, I do not believe that the UN has had as big of a role in this decline as the author believes. The initial idea of the UN was a noble one, but I don’t think that there is a way for one organization to take on the burden of stopping violent wars worldwide. It is kind of like creating a police agency for world crime. The chapter I found to be the most interesting was the fourth, because it talked about the role the UN has played in past conflicts. It was eye-opening to see the failures and successes of the organization and how the UN conducted itself in each of them. The conflict that was most intriguing to me was the Rwandan genocide. I saw Hotel Rwanda for the first time about a year ago, and I am ashamed to say that I had not heard much about it until then. Reading the part about the conflict in Chapter 4 really added to the little information I knew about it.
The most amazing part of it, for me, was that airplanes were sent in to come pick up the foreigners living in the area when the cause seemed to be a lost one. The planes could have at least brought aid supplies with them on the way there and unloaded them to make room for passengers getting transport out of Rwanda. Instead, empty planes came and took the foreigners away, without giving any aid to the people in the area who were suffering. This really sends the message that the rest of the world has given up and that the country was going to be left on its own to deal with its own problems. This example can be used to illustrate the point that organizations like the UN are flawed in that they will not work in every situation. There are cultural clashes that cannot be solved by sending a third party in to intervene. When these attempts fail, the countries left behind usually suffer more than they did before, because they feel as though they are hopeless cases.
Quiz Question: What is the name of the founder, main architect, and director of UN peacekeeping operations at its beginning?
Research Question: How do countries receiving aid from the UN feel when the services they provide are rescinded?

Friday, March 2, 2012

The Tropic of Chaos

Overall, this book was great. I loved how Parenti brought the events in his book to life. The best way to really understand other cultures is to look at 'case studies' of individuals and how they view what goes on. I did catch some inconsistencies in the book, but because of the spirit of the book and the fact that it was obviously written to bring attention to an area of research that has not been paid much attention previously, I could still read the book and not be bothered too much. What I took from the book was Parenti's main idea of 'catastrophic convergence', that climate change is interacting with and accelerating cultural and historical factors that already existed.

What I found interesting about the book was that the 'Tropic of Chaos' located in the Inter-tropical Convergence Zone did not include some of the areas he talked about, and some of the areas he should have included in the book were nowhere to be found. I would have liked to learn even more about places not often on the news such as Vietnam, Cambodia, and Papua New Guinea. However, there is only so much information that can be included in a book while still remaining connected to the main idea and not seem like the author is rambling. Another aspect of climate change I would have liked to hear more about is how the warmer temperatures worldwide are affecting plant and animal populations. Parenti goes over the melting glaciers and the effect global warming is having on agriculture, but not much about how it is affecting natural vegetation and wild animal species. I would also be interested to hear about how global warming is affecting populations that live solely of the land (hunter-gatherers). An important connection I think the author made was between the climate change being experienced in Afghanistan and their subsequent switch to growing poppy instead of other crops. It added another facet to the culture of the Taliban, and made me understand more why they have support from the local populations (the Taliban protects poppy farmers from NATO forces fighting against the drug trade).

After finishing the last chapter of the book, I was sitting thinking about the main idea; how climate change was accelerating violence in certain parts of the world. For a long time, assumingly because of the news I’ve been exposed to about Afghanistan/Iraq/Pakistan, I have thought that the violence there is caused by ‘bad people’, like the people who are born and raised in these countries are just bad because of their culture or their religion. However, after thinking more about it and putting some of my psychology knowledge to work, I came up with a different conclusion. I’m not sure if anyone reading this has heard of the Stanford Prison Experiment, but it was an experiment done at Stanford University in 1971 that took students and put them in either guard or prisoner positions. What happened was amazing. The participants took it very seriously; the guards were brutal and the prisoners all had a horrible time – some needed years of therapy afterwards. But the main idea of the study was to see what would happen when good people were put in an evil place. Their question was essentially: Does good nature trump institution? The answer to this question was no. All participants in the study were ‘good’ people, but became violent under these circumstances. Mind you, all participants were men, but it still can apply because most of the ‘bad people’ we think of in Middle Eastern countries are men. They may not all be inherently bad because of their culture or religion. It may be that they are good people, but growing up in such a bad place has hardened them. It may not be entirely appropriate to place all blame on their religion, though following a fundamentalist religion has been proven to  have the side effect of a decrease in overall happiness.

Overall, I am very glad I read this book. I learned a lot about the history of continents I don’t hear about very often, and I also learned about the struggles of the populations in the Tropic of Chaos. My thoughts after reading the book are that climate change is certainly having a negative impact on many countries, making it difficult for them to continue positive development. Help is needed, but because the historical and cultural aspects of these countries are rooted in oppression by countries like the United States and sometimes even the United States itself, it may be hard for them to accept the help. NGO’s and humanitarian groups are doing a great job, but more obviously needs to be done, with a certain respect for culture (like not putting a well smack in the middle of a dividing line between two warring populations).