Sunday, February 26, 2012

Water Flows or Blood

It is almost impossible to imagine a natural disaster that killed two thousand people and left fourteen million in need of humanitarian aid. 2.4 million hectares of farmland was swept away and 1.9 million homes were destroyed, leaving 7 million people without a home after the 2010 Arabian Ocean Monsoon that flooded 20% of Afghanistan. In the United States, our biggest recent natural disaster was Hurricane Katrina, and while I will always remember the video of those displaced after all the flooding and destruction, I still can’t picture the scale of what must have been lost after the monsoon in Afghanistan. To fully understand the extent of the effect of climate change on places like Afghanistan, Pakistan, India, etc., it is important to have knowledge of the political, cultural, and historical context of the destruction. In places lacking in infrastructure, bouncing back from a large-scale natural disaster is a monumental undertaking and in most circumstances never fully happens.
In chapter 9, I was very interested in how opium, because of its minimal water needs, has taken hold in Afghanistan as one of its chief exports. It is another part of ‘law enforcement’ in Afghanistan that I never think about. NATO forces try to shut down poppy farmers, but because the crop is so profitable, the Taliban defends it and therefore gets the loyalty of the farmers who enjoy the Taliban’s protection. In chapter 11, I was interested to read about the disputes over the Kashmir region and how even this is related to Pakistan’s support of the Taliban (because India and Pakistan are fighting over control of the rivers that flow in this region, Pakistan supports the Taliban presence in Afghanistan because it makes the country a weaker ally for India). Finally, in chapter 12, I was saddened to hear about how many farmers, because of drought and subsequent lack of resources to grow crops, have resorted to suicide out of desperation. 150,000 farmers committed suicide between 1997 and 2005. That’s a substantial number...  It amazes me that banks in this region, instead of supporting the local economy by encouraging cultivation of a diverse number of crops, only support the growth of cotton because it ensures that the farmers and their starving families will not skim a little bit of their product off the top so they can have something to eat. Added to this, the cotton grown is killing the land because it is genetically engineered and does not allow for biodiversity, and therefore the development of a healthy ecosystem.
It seems to me that most of the things going on in the regions we have been reading about in this book are the result of greed and lack of respect for others. I do not think that it is right of me to judge the people in these countries for taking advantage of each other, because I cannot even come close to understanding what they are going through, but it seems like throughout history, more good has come out of working together than from one group milking the weaker parts of the population for all they have and then controlling them. People may just be trying to get by the only way they know how. This is a reason why first-world countries like the United States should be sending aid to help with irrigation projects and well-drilling. But even the best intentions can become skewed when there is little oversight and greed comes into play. In the book, Parenti mentions that there are NGO’s operating in places like Afghanistan that are charging money to drill wells, a service that should be free. 

Quiz Question: What fraction of India’s population consists of farmers?
Research Question: How can some of the agricultural irrigation techniques used in the United States be applied to the hardships currently being experienced in the Middle East?

Friday, February 24, 2012

Five Ways to Save the World

I really liked this movie. I thought the solutions scientists have come up with so far are innovative, although not all of them seemed possible/plausible. I have seen the ‘sunshade’ idea before, on another show I think, and I think this is the coolest one, but it may not be very doable. Putting thin sheets of glass into outer space would be an expensive undertaking, and with the space dust and small rocks floating through space, what would happen if some of the shades were dusty or broken and the shades lost their reflectiveness or structure? The second idea seems more realistic. There are already things being done to manipulate clouds, so it is not as far-fetched as the sunshade idea. Putting 50 ships in the middle of the ocean that create seawater mist which rises into the clouds and eventually thickens the cloud cover does not seem like it will create too many unwanted side effects, although it is hard to tell until this idea is implemented.
The third idea was the ‘sulfur screen’. This was my least favorite; I understand the idea that the scientist was going for, but it seems like putting that much sulfur into the atmosphere would be detrimental to life on the planet’s surface. Acid rain and upper respiratory disease sound like pretty intense side effects for this idea. The ocean engineer’s idea of increasing phytoplankton is my second favorite idea; but it is hard to predict how tweaking this delicate ecosystem will affect the rest of the ocean life. The fifth and final idea was my favorite. Artificial trees that capture carbon from the air seem like a plausible undertaking. The storage of this carbon seems less so, but that is possibly just because I do not understand fully how they would do it. Because we already have ‘wind farms’ with wind turbines to harness wind energy, these ‘tree’ structures may be able to be installed on these already existing structures, saving some money.
Overall, I am happy to see that so many people are coming up with a variety of ideas to reduce the effects of global warming. It is refreshing to not hear about the controversy and debate surrounding this issue; it is now an established, factual process and there are people trying to solve it. (though politicians seem to be a little behind in this... ) Hopefully in the next 5-10 years we will see some of these ideas implemented around the country (or in outer space, of course).

Sunday, February 19, 2012

Climate-Driven

Let me start this post off by saying that I tried for about 30 minutes to find the area Parenti talks about at the beginning of chapter four where the Pokot raiders cross into Turkana territory on Google Earth with no luck. Most of the landmarks that she mentions are not labeled (I guess Google doesn’t think many people will be looking at this area of Kenya...).  I did not find the second part of the book as interesting as the first; the fourth chapter was the one that peaked my attention the most. The insights of those who were relatively native to the area were interesting to hear. There is a different feel to perspectives of locals; they have more comments about how certain factors affect everyday life.
To think that 1/3 of Earth’s land mass will be desert by 2100, and ½ of the total land surface will suffer drought is very powerful. I am not sure exactly how much of the Earth’s surface is used not only by humans, and by the plants and animals we live off of, but it seems like we probably use over half. For me, most of this reading was spent trying to picture how the people Parenti talks about actually live, because I know that to really understand how climate change affects them, I first have to think about their daily life and their living conditions to begin with. I then thought about how changes in the weather affect my life. When it rains, it takes longer to get to anywhere I’m going because traffic gets really bad, I have to worry about my patio furniture getting wet, etc. On a larger scale, this year because we have not had many storms come through, I have not been able to go up to Truckee to go skiing since there is such little snow. Although these problems are small, they are some ways that the weather affects my life. I can only imagine what life would be like if the rain and flooding that followed literally ruined my life because it took off all the topsoil from my fields and I no longer had any way to support my family. It is so easy to separate yourself from the rest of the world by just assuming people like the Pokot and Turkana have the resources to recover from erratic weather patterns and that ‘they’ll be okay’. If they were struggling to begin with, it is just not that simple.

Thursday, February 16, 2012

Beyond Belief

I really enjoyed the documentary Beyond Belief. It was inspiring first of all to see the two widows overcome their grief from the loss of their husbands. It was even more amazing to me to see them transform themselves from ‘the 9-11 widows’ into two women who strive to help struggling widows in Afghanistan. The bike ride was a great idea, and I like how they combined something that they (or at least one of them) were passionate about (bike riding) with a way to find closure and bring in money to help those in need.
Personally, my favorite part of the movie was when the two women went to Afghanistan and experienced what life was like there. It was amazing for me to see how the widows of Afghanistan reacted to the two women and what kinds of questions they asked. When one of the American widows was asked what her house looked like, I just thought how much I would not like to be asked that question, even though I only live in a one-bedroom apartment. This aspect of their visit brings up a question, however. How much can/do you give? Many non-profits trying to raise money for causes will tell you to skip your Starbucks for a week and donate that money to their organization. Well, if you are going to do that, why not donate the money you spend on seeing movies, on your gym membership, or your ‘going out’ weekend money? Why not sell your car and get a much cheaper one, and give the difference to a cause? Sometimes it seems frivolous to be spending money on any of these things when you think about how people are living in other countries. But how far should someone go? Is there an understanding that a certain standard of living is ‘okay’ to have in the United States just because you live here, even if some of your spending may be unnecessary?
This movie brought up a second idea as well. During some of their meetings, the women’s organization was talking about what exactly they wanted to buy with the money they had raised. One of the widows wanted to really find out what the widows in Afghanistan needed. This made me start thinking about how someone would figure out this information. It’s not like there is a census bureau in Afghanistan that keeps track of households and what happens to the people in them. It would be a good idea, if this hasn’t already been implemented, for humanitarian aid organizations to do this.

Sunday, February 12, 2012

Ethnoliberation Opportunism

Tropic of Chaos has me hooked from the start. I never really think about how climate change affects those people who don’t have many ways to deal with the rapid adaptations it requires. I have never lived off of land in the sense that I have farmed for my food, but I can imagine how hard it would be if all of a sudden all of your cattle and crops died and you didn’t have something like a supermarket to go to. I was amazed at the number of people climate change affects, as well, and how many it is expected to affect in 2030. The composition of most of the cultures/populations that live in the ‘tropic of chaos’ would make it difficult for them, and consequent violence is almost inevitable as people fight for the dwindling resources. I was most interested to read the third chapter, which talked about counterinsurgency (COIN) tactics and how they have been used historically. I am very interested in culture; how it is constructed, what determines its structure and customs, as well as its politics. For me, culture is something that should be preserved and respected, not destroyed and taken advantage of. 
On the surface, COIN goals sound pretty reasonable to me. If you are trying to work with a country to make it better, you would help those that could not help themselves and who did not have part in the fighting (managing refugees), make sure that factions within the country worked out a system which worked for both parties (keep peace between warring factions), and control the violence that came along with the growing change within the country (attack renegade militias). These are the three goals of counterinsurgency, and would be more effective and humanitarian if the people giving the ‘help’ had the country’s best interests in mind. However, most of these COIN projects are meant to control the population of a country so that more powerful forces can benefit. Culture is not constructed using a manual; therefore each culture is something original and unique, no matter what some of its quirks may be. I believe wholeheartedly that cultures should be left to develop on their own, without unneeded influence from other cultures. For example, if humanitarian aid is needed to help refugees or certain populations who have experienced catastrophic loss of resources, more powerful countries with those resources should step in to help. To go into a country, however, with the sole purpose of changing a culture and instigating a political system that only caters to powerful countries’ needs, is pretty wrong. The fact that counterinsurgency forces burn crops and destroy a country’s means of producing its own food so that the people there will be completely dependent on food handouts from those forces is backwards. That is no way to treat anyone. From my psychology background, it kind of sounds domestic violence, like what batterers do to their victims. If someone is completely dependent on a more powerful person, that person has full control. Overall, I really enjoyed reading about how the force of global warming/climate change can act as an accelerant to violence worldwide, and also made me think about how a drop in access to resources may make smaller, less powerful countries even more vulnerable to invasion by counterinsurgency forces. 

Quiz Question: What are the three COIN main goals/tasks?
Research Question: How is the culture of less powerful countries merged with the goals and ideals of the United States when they are invaded? Is it completely lost or do some aspects survive? 

Wednesday, February 8, 2012

What I Know

What I know about the rest of the world is based mostly on the news articles I have read and what I have heard from my teachers and friends/family. Because I am a Behavioral Science/Psychology major, I know a good deal about other cultures and some of the different customs that exist worldwide. One class that stood out from all others for me was a Sociology of Media class that I took last year. In this class, I learned about the many organizations and people that control the content of national news and what is shown and not shown. Since then, I have not seriously paid attention to any news stations except for the occasional Daily Show with John Stewart. What I know about the rest of the world is that there are many suffering people and that most of their suffering is caused by the greed and arrogance of others in their quest for power. I also know that many of these people are women and their children, and that many of them have no means to better themselves. When I first started to learn these things about the world, I thought the outlook seemed pretty hopeless and I was pretty disenchanted. However, with a little research and optimism, I have discovered that there are many people willing to help that are making a difference, if only a small one, in the lives of those suffering worldwide. In this geography class, I hope to learn a little more about the world and discover sources I can use to get relatively unbiased information. I know almost nothing about world conflict, to the point where the first I heard about the Rwandan genocide was from the Hotel Rwanda movie. Shameful, I know, but I am willing to learn and fill in the enormous gaps in my knowledge base.

Sunday, February 5, 2012

Infoganda

What I understood from chapters 4, 5, and 6 of Why America Fights was the general point that those in charge of United States’ foreign relations seem to feel compelled to ‘save’ other countries from themselves. Because smaller, less established countries are so backwards, it is America’s job to show them how it’s done, even when they really don’t have any interest in doing so. What stood out to me from these three chapters is the myriad ways in which propagandists appeal to the many views that exist within our country. In the fourth chapter, the author mentions that most Americans do not hear about foreign/international relations enough to have an informed opinion about what they think should happen. Because this is so, propaganda organizations decided that instead of creating a way in which to better inform the public about international issues, they would just try to sway the opinions of those who were already informed. It seems to me that if our government wanted to be so included in helping other nations accept and adopt democratic values, it would be a good idea to help our own citizens understand where those countries are developing from. A second point I took from the chapters was that, although the wars highlighted seem different from one another, they are mostly fought for the same reasons. The United States sends our military in under the guise that they are going to protect democratic values and ensure safety for the worlds’ populations. Most of the time, the reasons we want to have a military presence in other countries is that we want to have economic access to worldwide markets. I enjoyed this book overall, it was interesting to read because it went into detail about which government organizations come up with which propaganda and how those with power in the U.S. decide to use it to their advantage.
Quiz Question: Why did President Truman feel that it was necessary to portray the world in such ‘black and white’ terms during the war in Korea?
Research Question: How many people in countries like Iraq and Afghanistan actually know why American troops are in their country?