Sunday, February 12, 2012

Ethnoliberation Opportunism

Tropic of Chaos has me hooked from the start. I never really think about how climate change affects those people who don’t have many ways to deal with the rapid adaptations it requires. I have never lived off of land in the sense that I have farmed for my food, but I can imagine how hard it would be if all of a sudden all of your cattle and crops died and you didn’t have something like a supermarket to go to. I was amazed at the number of people climate change affects, as well, and how many it is expected to affect in 2030. The composition of most of the cultures/populations that live in the ‘tropic of chaos’ would make it difficult for them, and consequent violence is almost inevitable as people fight for the dwindling resources. I was most interested to read the third chapter, which talked about counterinsurgency (COIN) tactics and how they have been used historically. I am very interested in culture; how it is constructed, what determines its structure and customs, as well as its politics. For me, culture is something that should be preserved and respected, not destroyed and taken advantage of. 
On the surface, COIN goals sound pretty reasonable to me. If you are trying to work with a country to make it better, you would help those that could not help themselves and who did not have part in the fighting (managing refugees), make sure that factions within the country worked out a system which worked for both parties (keep peace between warring factions), and control the violence that came along with the growing change within the country (attack renegade militias). These are the three goals of counterinsurgency, and would be more effective and humanitarian if the people giving the ‘help’ had the country’s best interests in mind. However, most of these COIN projects are meant to control the population of a country so that more powerful forces can benefit. Culture is not constructed using a manual; therefore each culture is something original and unique, no matter what some of its quirks may be. I believe wholeheartedly that cultures should be left to develop on their own, without unneeded influence from other cultures. For example, if humanitarian aid is needed to help refugees or certain populations who have experienced catastrophic loss of resources, more powerful countries with those resources should step in to help. To go into a country, however, with the sole purpose of changing a culture and instigating a political system that only caters to powerful countries’ needs, is pretty wrong. The fact that counterinsurgency forces burn crops and destroy a country’s means of producing its own food so that the people there will be completely dependent on food handouts from those forces is backwards. That is no way to treat anyone. From my psychology background, it kind of sounds domestic violence, like what batterers do to their victims. If someone is completely dependent on a more powerful person, that person has full control. Overall, I really enjoyed reading about how the force of global warming/climate change can act as an accelerant to violence worldwide, and also made me think about how a drop in access to resources may make smaller, less powerful countries even more vulnerable to invasion by counterinsurgency forces. 

Quiz Question: What are the three COIN main goals/tasks?
Research Question: How is the culture of less powerful countries merged with the goals and ideals of the United States when they are invaded? Is it completely lost or do some aspects survive? 

3 comments:

  1. Last summer, I took Meteorology 112 that discussed a lot of what Parenti has mentioned excluding the violence. I find it interesting that I can incorporate what I learned from that course with Tropic of Chaos. I knew climate change affects people all over the world, but never thought it could influence violence. I was not too sure if I was for counterinsurgency because like you said, “COIN projects are meant to control the population of a country so that more powerful forces can benefit”. I am hoping Parenti discusses more about COIN and provides more examples too.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm also really interested in culture which why I decided to minor in anthropology. It's actually quite interesting that reading this book is helping me piece together cultural, social,and political factors related to climate change. I must admit, I haven't really thought much about counterinsurgency much less connect it to violence due to climate change. I liked how you added your knowledge from psychology into your response. I agree that it is pretty messed up to go inside the system to only destroy it from the inside to the out.

    On the side note, I think it would be easier to read your blog if your responses are properly spaced and divided into paragraphs.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I love what you said about culture not being constructed with a manual, and how you related psychology to COIN forces. I'm biased, because I am a psychology major - and your analogy of domestic violence put it in a different and understandable light for me!

    ReplyDelete